Caught Lookin’: A Cleveland Guardians Podcast

In the Season 1 finale of Caught Lookin’, Meg, Nicole, Madelyn, Ali, and Ash break down the Guardians’ most recent signings before spending the rest of the episode talking about their favorite players and why they’ll always ride for their guys. It’s a fitting send-off to 2025 as we wrap our first season.

Meg, Jenell, Molly, and Mary are back after the Thanksgiving break and catching up on all things Guardians. This week, we break down the latest signings, look ahead to the Winter Meetings, and kick around some trade possibilities we’d love (or maybe not love) to see. We also give a brief update on the developing Clase/Ortiz situation and what it could mean moving forward.

This week, we’re doing something a little different. To celebrate the holiday season and wrap up an unforgettable year of Guardians baseball, the Caught Lookin’ crew is coming together to share what we’re most thankful for — on the field, in the fanbase, and within this incredible community that’s grown around the team.

Featuring contributions from Meg, Nicole, Ali, Molly, Mary, Kels, Sarah, and Mikayla, with a special thanks to Wundy for her editing genius, this episode is a warm, reflective look at the moments, players, and memories that makes this team special.

Whether yo...

Meg, Sarah, Kels, and Mikayla are back for a jam-packed Episode 13! We kick things off with the latest Guardians news before diving into a special edition of Mikayla’s Card Corner featuring a full recap of Her Hobby Night. Then we shift gears to basketball — breaking down the Cavs’ recent ups and downs, giving our honest takes on the past and present City Edition jerseys, and some nostalgia as we revisit the legendary 2016 Cavs run.

It’s finally here! Meg, Nicole, Ali, and Madelyn present the First Annual Lookin’ Back Awards, celebrating the very best (and most chaotic) moments of the Guardians’ 2025 season.

From Team MVP to Comeback Player of the Year, Biggest Aura Farmer, Most Likely to Forget What Inning It Is, and plenty more, the Lookie winners are officially crowned — all chosen by you, the fans.

It’s fun, it’s unhinged in all the right ways, and it’s the perfect way to close the book on the 2025 season. Tune in now for all the Lookies!

In Episode 11 of Caught Lookin’, Meg, Ash, Sarah, and Kels dive into the serious news surrounding the recent indictment of Emmanuel Clase and Luis Ortiz — breaking down what’s known so far, the wider implications for the team, and how fans are processing it all.

In Episode 10 of Caught Lookin’, Meg, Ali, and Mikayla dive into the latest baseball talk — from Guardians bullpen usage and the World Series, to new baseball card releases and more. Tune in for analysis, laughs, and plenty of Cleveland energy!

In Episode 9 of Caught Lookin’, Meg, Mary, Nicole, and Jenell break down all the latest Guards news — including Carl Willis returning, a possible Stephen Vogt extension?, the looming uncertainty of the Clase/Ortiz situation, potential Progressive Field promos for the 2026 season, and more.

In Episode 8 of Caught Lookin’, Meg, Sarah, and Kels are joined by special guest Gabb Goudy to talk all things Cleveland sports! The crew breaks down recent Guardians news — including Kai Correa heading to the Mets and Austin Hedges re-signing — before diving into a full Cavs season preview, including roster expectations to vibes around the team.

In Episode 7 of Caught Lookin’, Meg, Ali, Jenell, Mikayla, and Nicole break down Vogt and Antonetti’s postseason press conference, share thoughts on why this year’s ALCS and NLCS might just be the most “ethical playoffs” ever, dive into the new Topps Three Kings Rewards Program, and more!

In Episode 6 of Caught Lookin’, Meg, Kelsey, Sarah, Ash, and first-time guest Molly wrap up the 2025 Guardians season and reflect on the highs, lows, and what’s next for the team. The crew also looks ahead to their hopes for next season—and teases some exciting off-season content in the works!

In Episode 5 of Caught Lookin’, Meg, Jenell, Madelyn, Ash, and first-time guest Mary celebrate the Guardians clinching the AL Central and making history with their incredible comeback. The crew previews the upcoming playoffs and shares their own bracket predictions—who do they think goes all the way? Tune in to find out!

In Episode 4 of Caught Lookin’, Meg, Ali, Sarah, and first-time guest Kelsey break down the Guardians’ current playoff race and recent team performance, including a sweep in the doubleheader and a look ahead to the upcoming series against the Tigers. They wrap things up with a rapid-fire Q&A, answering questions straight from the fans!

Episode 3 of Caught Lookin’ is here! Meg, Nicole, Sarah, Mikayla, and first-time guest Jenell dive into the Guardians’ recent success against the Royals and White Sox, explore playoff possibilities, discuss the upcoming Bowman Chrome release, an exclusive announcement from Mikayla, answer fan Q&A, and more!

Meg, Ali, Ash, and Madelyn are back for Episode 2 of Caught Lookin’! The crew dives into the Guardians’ surprising playoff push, possible lineup shake-ups, and Madelyn shares the story of her unforgettable afternoon hanging out with her favorite player, Nick Wittgren.

Meg, Nicole, Sarah, and Mikayla kick off the very first episode of Caught Lookin’! We break down the Guardians’ series with the Mariners, dig into September call-ups, dive into The Hobby of baseball card collecting, and of course - talk Steven Kwan. All that and more in our debut episode!

Caught Looking is a Cleveland Guardians–focused baseball podcast hosted by a rotating crew of women and non-binary fans who love the game — and love talking about it just as much. Each week, we break down the latest from the Corner of Carnegie and Ontario: game highlights, player moments, fan culture, merch, ballpark vibes, and the chaos in between. This show centers voices that are too often sidelined in sports talk. No guys behind the mic — just smart, funny, passionate people bringing a fresh perspective to Cleveland baseball. Whether you're here for hot takes, heartbreaks, or home runs — don’t get caug...